What HR Directors should look for in internal communications

Assessing internal communications support starts with understanding what your existing team can achieve, what might be holding it back and where additional expertise is genuinely needed. Appointing an agency is one possible outcome, not the starting assumption.

For HR directors and senior transformation leaders, these eight checks provide a practical way to review internal capability, identify gaps and assess external support where appropriate.

1. Assess your team’s strategic contribution

An internal communication strategy should connect organisational priorities with what colleagues need to understand and do. Can your team explain those connections and prioritise its work accordingly?

Look at when it becomes involved in decisions. Helping shape a change programme requires different access and authority from producing an announcement after everything has been agreed.

Before identifying a skills gap, check whether the team has a clear remit, access to leaders and permission to challenge competing requests. Ask what it would stop doing to give the most important work enough attention.

2. Test its understanding of different employee audiences

Follow a recent communication about benefits, business priorities or working practices. How did colleagues receive it? Could they explain what it meant for them? Where did they go with questions?

Include people on shifts, across sites, away from a desk or working in another language. Assess whether your team understands their circumstances and accounts for accessibility and access to devices.

Look for employee communications informed by conversations and feedback, alongside channel data. Publishing a message doesn’t establish that everyone has received or understood it.

3. Review leadership messaging and manager support

Consider how your team helps leaders explain decisions and prepares managers to discuss them. Do managers receive enough notice, context and practical guidance? Can they raise questions they cannot answer?

During change, communication should distinguish what is confirmed, what remains uncertain and when colleagues will hear more. Where jobs could be affected, establish how HR, employee relations and corporate communications work together.

A useful assessment is to ask managers what they actually use and what is missing. A briefing pack isn’t evidence of support if nobody has time to work through it.

4. Examine how listening informs culture and communication

If openness is a stated value, what happens when colleagues challenge a decision? If wellbeing matters, can people use the support available?

Your internal comms team should be able to identify contradictions between organisational messages and everyday experience. It needs permission to raise them, too. Don’t expect HR communications to compensate for working practices that undermine the message.

Review how employee feedback reaches decision-makers, what it influences and how colleagues hear what happened afterwards. Listening should inform decisions as well as the next campaign.

5. Judge effectiveness beyond the volume of output

Agree what successful internal support should achieve. For a strategy launch, assess whether colleagues understand the priorities. For a new process, examine whether people know what to do and whether adoption changes.

Channel data can help explain reach and response, but email opens alone don’t establish employee engagement. Avoid attributing wider business outcomes entirely to communication.

Ask your team what the evidence suggests, what remains uncertain and what it would change. Its ability to learn and adjust matters alongside the results of an individual programme.

6. Decide what kind of support the gap requires

Bring the assessment together. Is the constraint capability, capacity, access to decisions or unclear priorities?

Some gaps call for internal development, recruitment or a clearer remit. Others may justify specialist agency support: audience research, independent strategic advice, a complex change programme or creative development beyond the team’s available resources.

Be specific about the contribution needed. An agency won’t resolve a lack of internal ownership simply by producing more materials. Involve your team in deciding what to retain internally and where outside expertise would help.

7. Assess an agency against that specific need

If external support is appropriate, test its thinking as well as its portfolio. How would it investigate your challenge? What would it need to understand before recommending an approach?

Examine relevant work and ask how audience insight shaped the strategy and creative idea. What was the intended employee response? How was it evaluated? What proved difficult?

Look for cultural judgement and the confidence to question an unsuitable brief. Relevant experience needn’t mean an identical project in your sector, but the agency should explain how its expertise applies to your organisation and provide supporting evidence.

8. Establish how internal and external teams will work together

Involve your internal comms team in selection and briefing. Agree who owns strategy, provides insight, briefs leaders, manages channels, approves materials and evaluates progress.

Establish who will deliver the work, how disagreements will be handled and how scope and costs will be managed. Discuss what remains with your team afterwards, such as editable materials, research findings or new skills.

At Blue Goose, we shape measurement around each company and campaign. Whatever partner you choose, agree an evaluation approach that helps your team make better decisions, not simply report activity.

Start with a fair assessment

Your review may show that a capable internal team needs clearer priorities or earlier involvement, rather than an agency. It may reveal a specific need for external expertise. The important thing is to distinguish between them.

Assess what your team delivers and the conditions it works within. Then choose the support that addresses the actual gap.

To discuss where specialist support could complement your internal team, email Blue Goose at hello@bluegoose.co.uk.